View All Brands View Women's Health View Men's Health View My Favorite Product Selections View Details About How You Can Save More With Our Unique Super Saver Program Express Shop, The Quickest & Easiest Way To Shop
Health Library SEARCH
Health Library Home

Alternate-Day Fasting vs. Daily Caloric Restriction for Weight Loss

The quest for the perfect weight loss diet has led some to try alternate-day fasting—restricting calories on “fast” days, and not restricting calories on “feast” days. But is this method worth the sacrifice? Maybe not, according to research published in JAMA Internal Medicine. The research found that, while alternate-day fasting may yield the same weight loss as everyday calorie restriction, it may be harder to stick to in the long run.

The study included 100 participants between 18 and 64 years old who were obese but otherwise healthy. Researchers calculated how many calories each participant normally ate each day and considered this to be their baseline calorie intake. Then, they randomly assigned participants to one of two weight loss intervention groups or a control group: participants assigned to the alternate-day fasting intervention were instructed to eat 25% of their baseline calories on fast days and 125% of their baseline calories on feast days; participants assigned to the daily calorie restriction intervention were instructed to eat 75% of their baseline calories every day; and, the control group was instructed to eat normally, with no calorie restrictions. After six months, daily calorie intake levels were revised for the weight loss groups to instead support weight maintenance. At months six and twelve, researchers measured the participants’ weight loss and diet adherence, as well as health markers such as blood pressure, insulin resistance, and LDL cholesterol (“bad” cholesterol). At the end of the study, they found that:

  • The alternate-day fasting group and calorie restriction group lost similar amounts of weight after both six months and one year. At the end of the trial, they had lost 6% and 5.3% more weight, respectively, than the control group.
  • Participants in the alternate-day fasting group were less adherent to their intervention: on average, they ate more on fast days and less on feast days than they were instructed to eat, while the calorie restriction group generally ate as they were directed.
  • More participants dropped out of the alternate-day fasting group (38%) than out of the calorie restriction group (29%) or the control group (26%).
  • The alternate-day fasting group had increased levels of LDL-cholesterol compared with the calorie restriction group, but there were no significant differences in blood pressure, insulin resistance, or other health markers between the two groups.

These findings suggest alternate-day fasting and calorie restriction are likely to result in similar amounts of weight loss, but alternate-day fasting may be harder to maintain, and may even have a negative impact on LDL-cholesterol—a known cardiovascular risk factor. Nonetheless, alternate-day fasting may be a sound option for those who would benefit from weight loss but don’t fare well with daily calorie restriction. After all, there really isn’t a “one size fits all” diet.

Source: JAMA Internal Medicine

Copyright © 2019 Healthnotes, Inc. All rights reserved.

Learn more about Healthnotes, the company.

Your Cart: (0) Total: $0.00
Share on Twitter Add to Google Plus Share on Facebook Email a Friend Share Tools

The following product(s) are related to this article:
Daily Multivitamin
by Pure Prescriptions
Starting at $29.97

[ View Details ]
Clinical Nutrients 45-Plus Women
by Integrative Therapeutics, Inc.
Starting at $35.00

[ View Details ]
Daily Stress Formula
by Pure Encapsulations
Starting at $31.30

[ View Details ]
Healthy & Quick Breakfast Ideas for Everyone Read more
Quick Tip
Figuring Out Gluten-Free School Lunches

Figuring Out Gluten-Free School Lunches

To help your child avoid feelings of "food envy," include at least one or two items in each lunch that look and feel just like their full-gluten counterparts.

Get more info on gluten-free eating.
Home | About Us | Doctor's Blog | Contact Us | Terms of Use & Privacy Policy | Patient Intake Form | Company
For Assistance, Please Call: 888-821-8808
*These statements have not been evaluated by the Food & Drug Administration. These products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.
© 2019 PureRXO. All Rights Reserved.
Driving Directions From: GO